Privy Real Estate Review: Comp Software for Non-Disclosure States

Privy pulls in Multiple Listing Service, or ā€˜MLS’, data (the same data agents use) and makes it available to investors, buyers, and sellers without having to hire a REALTORĀ®. In non-disclosure states like Texas, Louisiana, and Utah, it’s really a game-changer.

In this review, I’ll walk through what Privy offers, who it’s best for, how it actually works in practice (with screenshots), and where it falls short. By the end, you’ll know whether Privy is worth trying for your own situation.

My Disclosure: I paid for a Privy subscription out of my own pocket. This review is not sponsored, and Privy hasn’t given me any incentives to write it. What follows are my honest impressions as a paying customer, based on my own experience using the platform.

This guide is part of our Essential Resources, where we cover topics relevant to both Buyers and Sellers.

What Are Non-Disclosure States?

If you’re buying or selling a home in a non-disclosure state, you’ve probably run into one big problem: you can’t look up what nearby homes actually sold for. Unlike disclosure states, where sale prices are public record, non-disclosure states keep that information hidden. That makes it tough for FSBO sellers trying to set a realistic asking price, or independent buyers who want to know whether a particular listing is fairly priced. That’s where tools like Privy come in.

Full List of Non-Disclosure States

Before we get too far into the review, it’s worthwhile to establish that the main non-disclosure states are:

  • Alaska
  • Idaho
  • Kansas
  • Louisiana
  • Mississippi
  • Missouri (partial)
  • Montana
  • New Mexico
  • North Dakota
  • Texas
  • Utah
  • Wyoming

šŸ“Œ Note: Missouri is considered a ā€œpartialā€ non-disclosure state. Rules can vary by county.

If you’d like to see how disclosure fits in with other home buying and selling rules across the U.S., including things like attorney closing states, community property states, and more, we’ve put together a detailed guide here: Home Buying & Selling Rules by State.

šŸŽ Disclosure vs. Non-Disclosure Wrap-up

In disclosure states, every home sale is recorded at the county level and includes the actual sale price. That data is public, and sites like Zillow and Redfin simply pull it in to display ā€œSoldā€ prices on their listings. But in non-disclosure states, sale prices aren’t public record. That means even Zillow doesn’t know what a home really sold for… they only show list prices or estimates. If you’re used to casually browsing ā€œSoldā€ listings online, moving to a non-disclosure state can feel like flying blind.


Who Benefits from Privy?

Before diving into details and features, it helps to see where Privy actually has coverage. Below is Privy’s national data map.

Privy National Coverage Map
  • Blue areas = MLS coverage (direct access to sold data).
  • Red areas = MLS coverage coming soon.
  • Yellow areas = 3rd-party listing data (not as complete as MLS).
  • Gray background = public record data only (typical nationwide baseline).

What this means in practice:

  • If you’re in a blue metro area, you’ll see true MLS comps (sold prices, active listings, pending sales).
  • If you’re in a yellow area, Privy still works, but you’ll be relying more on 3rd-party feeds.
  • If you’re outside the color zones entirely, Privy won’t add much value today.

šŸ“ Why this matters: Whether you’re selling FSBO or buying independently, you’ll only benefit from Privy if it covers your market. For example, Dallas, Houston, Salt Lake City, St. Louis, and New Orleans are well-covered. More rural states like Wyoming or Alaska are not.

So, the first step in deciding whether Privy is useful to you is simply: check the map.

šŸ”Ž What Is 3rd-Party Listing Data?

When Privy doesn’t have a direct MLS feed in a market, it fills the gap with other sources. These are usually public-facing or syndicated feeds, such as:

  • Zillow/Redfin/Realtor.com listings (active & pending, but no sold prices in non-disclosure states).
  • Brokerage websites that push their listings through IDX agreements.
    • IDX is the system that lets agents display MLS listings on their own websites. It’s good for active listings, but doesn’t show everything an agent sees in the MLS, including sold prices in non-disclosure states.
  • County tax and assessor records where available (i.e., in disclosure states).

This data can still be useful. You’ll see what’s on the market and sometimes recent sale activity, but it’s not as complete or as fast to update as a true MLS feed.

šŸ“Œ Bottom line: Yellow = usable, but not bulletproof. Blue (direct MLS) is where Privy really shines.

FSBO Sellers: Pricing Without an Agent

One of the hardest parts of selling your home on your own is setting the right asking price. Price too high and your listing sits with no offers. Price too low and you leave money on the table. In disclosure states, you can pull up Zillow and see what the house down the street actually sold for. In non-disclosure states, you don’t get that luxury unless you’re using a tool like Privy.

Privy gives FSBO sellers access to MLS sold data, the same information agents rely on when they prepare a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA). That means you can do the work yourself, without needing an agent to hand you comps.

Here’s how to work through the process:

  • Find similar homes in your neighborhood (square footage, year built, bed/bath count).
  • Check recent sales — 90 days or less is best to reflect current market conditions.
  • Look at condition and updates — a freshly remodeled kitchen will sell differently than an outdated one, even if the homes are the same size.
  • Compare multiple comps — don’t rely on just one property; look for a range and see where yours fits.
  • Put in the reps — don’t stop at a couple of comps. Review at least a dozen recent sales in your area so you start to recognize patterns in pricing. The more you study, and the sooner you start, the sharper your sense of local value will become.

Privy gives you the dataset, but you still need to decide which comps are truly comparable. From there, it’s up to you to apply judgment and price your home in line with the market.

Independent Buyers: Checking if a Home is Fairly Priced

Buying a home without an agent means you don’t have someone feeding you comps or sharing their opinion of value, and in non-disclosure states, sites like Zillow can’t fill that gap. Without reliable sold prices, it’s hard to know if a seller’s list price is fair or inflated.

Privy gives you access to the same MLS data agents use, so you can check pricing yourself:

  • Confirm fairness – compare the list price of a home you’re considering against recent nearby sales.
  • Spot patterns – are most homes selling close to list, above it, or consistently below? This gives you leverage when making an offer.
  • Dial in your neighborhood – focus on sales in the exact area you want to buy, not just the whole city. Prices can vary street by street.
  • Build your intuition – review many sold homes, not just one or two, until you start to recognize the ā€œnormalā€ range for your market.

Privy won’t decide the right offer number for you, but it removes the blindfold. Instead of guessing or relying on a Zestimate, you can step into negotiations with real comps in hand.

Beyond FSBO: Investors and Market Insight

While FSBO sellers and independent buyers stand to gain a great deal from MLS sold data, Privy was originally designed with investors in mind. That’s why you’ll see options like:

  • Fix & Flip – surfaces homes that recently sold and were quickly resold at higher prices.
  • Teardown – flags properties bought primarily for land value.
  • Below Market – identifies homes selling at a discount compared to estimated value.
Investor Activity Filter

For investors, these tools make it easier to spot opportunities and track activity in specific neighborhoods.

Even if you’re not an investor, these features provide useful market context:

  • You can see where investors are actively buying and flipping.
  • You can gauge whether certain neighborhoods are trending up.
  • You can connect with agents who specialize in data-driven transactions.

Privy isn’t just about comps. It’s a robust market research platform. For FSBO sellers, that means better pricing. For buyers, it means smarter offers. And for investors, it can be a deal-finding engine.


Privy Pricing Plans

Privy isn’t free, but the pricing is straightforward. Plans differ mainly by how many states you want access to. You can pay month-to-month or choose an annual plan for a discount, typically saving the equivalent of one or two months compared to paying monthly. For short-term users, monthly access makes sense; for investors or frequent users, the annual option can be more cost-effective.

The prices shown below are for month-to-month access.

Plan

Monthly Price

Annual Price (with discount)

Best For

Key Features

Single-State Plan

~$47/mo

~$32/mo

FSBO sellers, independent buyers

Full MLS + public data for one state, comp search tools, map filters

3-State Plan

~$79/mo

~$53/mo

Multi-state buyers or investors

Adds cross-state access and investor activity filters

Nationwide Plan

~$119/mo

~$149/mo

Investors and analysts

Nationwide MLS/public data, investor filters, and export/report tools

Single-State Plan (~$47/month)

If you only care about comps in your home state, this is the most affordable option. It gives you full MLS coverage where available, plus all of Privy’s filters and features, just limited to one state. This option is probably perfect for most buyers or sellers in non-disclosure states.

3-State Plan (~$79/month)

For buyers and sellers who work across borders, or investors targeting multiple markets, this plan covers three states of your choice. It’s a solid middle ground if you need more than local access but don’t need nationwide data.

Nationwide Investor Plan (~$149/month)

This is the flagship plan. You get access to every state Privy covers, including investor overlays, market tracking, and more. If you’re only selling one house FSBO, you don’t need this, but if you’re serious about investing or research, this is the plan built for you.

Why a Short-Term Subscription Can Still Be Worth It

Here’s a trick many FSBO sellers and independent buyers don’t realize: you don’t need to subscribe forever. For the cost of a single month, you can:

  • Pull all the comps you need to price your home or evaluate a purchase.
  • Save/export the data for reference.
  • Cancel once you’ve done your homework.

Compared to hiring an agent just for a one-off CMA, a one-month Privy subscription is often cheaper and gives you more control.

How to Cancel Privy

Buying into a subscription model that you’ll know you want to cancel someday can be anxiety-inducing. To that end, I’ve gone through the cancellation process here, with screenshots to show you what the process looks like.

Bottom Line Up Front: Privy makes the process simple, straightforward, and non-combative. You also automatically retain access to Privy for the remainder of your subscription, even after you cancel.

1. Go to ā€œAccount/Billing.ā€

From the left-hand navigation menu, click Account/Billing to open your subscription settings.

Account/Billing Menu Selection

2. Select ā€œCancel Subscription.ā€

You’ll see your active plan displayed; choose the option to cancel. Privy will confirm that you’ll lose access to MLS data, investor matches, and analytics after your current billing cycle ends.

Initial Cancellation Screen
Subscription Cancellation Screen

3. Provide Feedback (optional).

Privy asks why you’re canceling. Options include missing features, expense, or just having met your goal. You can also rate how likely you are to use Privy again in the future.

Privy Subscription Cancellation Feedback Screen

4. Confirm Cancellation.

Once submitted, you’ll receive a confirmation that your account will remain active until the end of your billing period.

Cancellation Confirmation Screenshot

🟦 Good to Know: You can cancel anytime, and your access continues until your paid month or year ends. That means if you only need Privy for a short project, like analyzing comps before listing FSBO, you can sign up for one month, cancel right away, and still use the full remaining time.


How Privy Works for Comping

Whether you’re selling FSBO or buying without an agent, the workflow is the same: search, filter, review comps, and build your own sense of market value.

Here’s what it looks like inside Privy:

1. Search by Address or Zip

  • Start with your property or target area. You can search by zip code, city, or a specific address.
Privy Location Filter

2. Set Your Filters

  • Narrow the search to homes that are truly comparable.
  • Options include square footage range, beds/baths, year built, and Days on Market.
  • This is where Privy shines compared to Zillow; you can really dial in specifics.
Privy Property Filter, Main

3. See Sold Comps on the Map

  • Results appear as red ā€œSOLDā€ pins with actual sale prices attached.
  • Click any pin to drill into details.
Comp Map View

4. Review the Property Details

  • Each sold listing includes photos, remarks, days on market, and $/sqft.
  • These are pulled straight from the MLS and are not just estimates.
Listing Detail Main Info
Listing Detail Supporting Info

5. Compare Side by Side

  • Use the comparables table to see multiple sold homes at once.
  • Check how they stack up in price, size, and features.
Privy Comp Table/List

šŸ“Œ Privy doesn’t hand you a ā€œyour house is worth $Xā€ answer. It gives you the raw MLS data and the filters to slice it down, so you can make your own informed judgment.

6. Rinse and Repeat

  • One or two comps won’t tell the full story. Review a dozen or more until you start to see consistent pricing patterns.

🧮 Diligence Matters: To really build confidence in your pricing, aim to review at least 10–15 recently sold homes in your immediate area. The more you see, the faster you’ll develop that ā€œgut feelā€ for what’s truly a fair price.


Strengths of Privy

Privy stands out because it gives regular buyers and sellers access to tools that usually sit behind the agent paywall. Here are the biggest advantages:

  • Direct MLS access (where available): As discussed, rather than relying only on third-party feeds, Privy pulls actual MLS data. That means faster updates and more accurate sold prices.
  • Third-party data coverage: In areas where MLS isn’t available, Privy still aggregates public records and other listing sites so you aren’t left in the dark.
  • Powerful filters: Unlike Zillow’s simple filter controls, Privy lets you dial in details like square footage ranges, year built, days on market, and even price-per-square-foot. This is the difference between browsing and analyzing.
  • Side-by-side comparables: You can quickly line up sold and active properties to see what’s truly comparable. This includes photos, property details, and sale timelines.
  • Investor-focused features: Filters for ā€œbelow market,ā€ ā€œfix & flip,ā€ and ā€œteardownā€ properties make it useful beyond FSBO sellers. Even if you’re not investing, these tools help identify motivated sellers and unique opportunities.
  • Interactive map view: Sold properties, active listings, and investor picks show up visually. This makes it easy to spot trends or cluster activity in a neighborhood.
  • Short-term value: You don’t have to commit long-term. Even one month of access can get you all the comps you need to make a smart decision.

šŸ’” Zillow vs. Privy: Browse or Analyze?

Zillow is built for browsing and engagement. It assumes you want the easiest, prettiest interface, even if that means less control. It’s great for casual scrolling, but not for defining what truly counts as a comparable home.

Privy, on the other hand, is built for analyzing. It gives you fine-grained control over every variable, such as limiting results to sales within 90 days and limiting square footage variance. It also allows you to filter for homes with excessive days on market that might signal a motivated seller. Those kinds of filters make it far easier for buyers to identify hidden deals and for FSBO sellers to price competitively.


Limitations of Privy

No tool is perfect, and Privy has some trade-offs worth knowing about before you subscribe:

  • MLS access isn’t nationwide: Coverage depends on where Privy has data agreements. Some areas only have partial MLS coverage, so you may fall back on third-party data.
  • Less polished design: Privy’s interface isn’t as sleek or ā€œprettyā€ as Zillow’s. It’s functional and filter-rich, but you won’t get the same glossy browsing experience.
  • Pricing can add up: At $47/month (or more for multi-state access), it’s obviously more expensive than free sites. For one-off buyers or sellers, you’ll want to plan your timing so you don’t overpay.
  • Best features skew investor-focused: Tools like ā€œfix & flipā€ or ā€œbelow marketā€ filters are great for investors, but may feel unnecessary for a one-time FSBO seller.
  • Limited public data: In counties without full MLS coverage in non-disclosure states, you’ll still see incomplete or missing sold-price information.
  • No hand-holding: Privy gives you the data, but it doesn’t tell you how to interpret it. You still need to put in the work to know your market and choose the right comps.

Alternatives to Privy

Privy isn’t the only way to get comps. Depending on your budget, location, and how deep you want to go, there are other paths to the same end goal:

Other Comp Software (PropStream, DealCheck)

  • PropStream: A heavyweight tool used by investors, with nationwide property data, comps, and lead lists. More expensive and complex, but very powerful.
  • DealCheck: Budget-friendly, especially for analyzing rentals and flips. Not as strong on raw comps as Privy, but handy if you’re evaluating properties as investments.

One-Off CMA or Valuation Reports

Not everyone needs a monthly subscription. If you’re selling one property or just curious about a home’s value, a single CMA (Comparable Market Analysis) might be the better fit.

A CMA is a report that compares your home to recently sold, similar properties (ā€œcomparablesā€) in your area. Agents use it to estimate a fair market price. This is the same type of analysis they’d do before listing your home. While it’s not a formal Appraisal, a well-done CMA gives you a realistic view of what homes are actually selling for in your market. It’s based on similar data appraisers use, but focused on helping you price to sell rather than to satisfy a lender.

  • Flat-Fee CMA from an Agent:
    Many real estate agents will run a CMA for you even if you’re not hiring them to list your home. Costs vary, but you’ll typically pay $100–$250 for a one-time report. It’s basically the same pricing work they’d do if you were their client, but without the full-service package.
  • Online Valuation Services:
    Several websites sell one-off property valuation reports, often delivered instantly or within 24 hours.
    • USHomeValue.com (typically around $59–$99 per report): Provides detailed property value reports researched by licensed appraisers, not automated models. Reports include comparable sales and estimated value ranges, making them useful for owners or FSBO sellers who want more than a quick online estimate but don’t need a full appraisal.
    • HouseCanary (around $25–$50 per report): Well-regarded for AVMs (Automated Valuation Models).
  • When it makes sense:
    If you just need one snapshot. For example, to sanity-check your asking price before listing FSBO, this can potentially be cheaper than paying monthly for comp software. But, they’re using the same reference data you can get off Privy in their MLS coverage areas.

šŸ“Š Why an Appraisal Isn’t Always the Right Tool for Pricing

An appraisal sounds authoritative, but it’s designed for lenders, not for setting a list price. Appraisers aim to protect the bank’s risk, not to predict what a buyer will actually pay.

  • Purpose: Appraisals confirm value after an offer, not to help set an asking price.
  • Scope: They rely on closed sales only, not active listings or market momentum.
  • Cost: Typically $400–$700, with no added advantage for FSBO sellers.

If your goal is to understand where your home fits in the current market, a CMA or comp software like Privy is faster, cheaper, and focused on what really matters; buyer behavior and local price trends.

Free Options in Disclosure States

  • If you live in a disclosure state, sold data is public and much easier to find.
  • Tools like Zillow, Redfin, and county assessor websites often give you more than enough.
  • In these states, Privy adds convenience and precision, but it’s less essential.

Final Thoughts

Privy doesn’t replace your judgment, but enhances it. By cutting down the hours you’d otherwise spend piecing comps together, it makes FSBO sellers more confident and buyers more competitive. Think of it as a research companion: it won’t decide the price for you, but it will hand you the tools to make the decision smarter, faster, and on your own terms.

In my opinion, if you’re committed to buying or selling without an agent, Privy can be the edge that makes the difference between guessing and knowing.

This article is for education only. Our goal is to give you the tools to handle your own transaction. Whether you choose to involve an agent or attorney is always up to you.

Scroll to Top